Est. 2005  ·  Independent coverage for lawyers, advisers, financiers & in-house counsel in 150+ jurisdictions
Corporate INTL
Corporate INTL Newsroom · Dispute Resolution & Litigation

Trump New York Times Lawsuit: Why a Judge Let the $15bn Defamation Claim Proceed

By The Corporate INTL Newsroom · 20 November 2026

Tampa skyline at sunset, the city where the federal court ruled on the Trump New York Times lawsuit on 19 November 2026

The Trump New York Times lawsuit will go forward. On Thursday 19 November 2026, Senior US District Judge Steven D. Merryday in Tampa, Florida, partly refused to dismiss President Donald Trump's defamation claim against The New York Times Company, three of its journalists and Penguin Random House. Four of six counts survive, built on seven statements accusing Mr Trump of tax fraud and other wrongdoing. Two counts, and 27 of the 34 challenged statements, were thrown out.

The 12-page order decides only that the claim is plausibly pleaded, but media lawyers will study its reasoning: the judge held that writers who accuse someone of a complex crime without first obtaining "an explicit opinion from a qualified source" may be engaged in "purposeful avoidance of the truth", which can amount to actual malice even under New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. The case now moves towards discovery.

The Trump New York Times lawsuit ruling at a glance

The ruling keeps the core of the case: tax-fraud allegations in the 2024 book Lucky Loser and one passage in an October 2024 Times article.

PointWhat the order says
CaseTrump v. New York Times Company, No. 8:25-cv-2487 (M.D. Fla.)
Judge and dateSenior District Judge Steven D. Merryday, 19 November 2026 (Doc. 109)
DefendantsThe New York Times Company, Susanne Craig, Russ Buettner, Peter Baker and Penguin Random House LLC
Counts that surviveCounts I and II (the book) and Counts V and VI (the October 2024 article)
Counts dismissedCounts III and IV (the September 2024 article on The Apprentice)
Statements7 may proceed; 27 held not actionable as defamation published with actual malice
Next stepDefendants must answer within 28 days
Damages claimedNot less than $15 billion, plus punitive damages and retraction

What Trump alleged against the Times and Penguin Random House

Mr Trump says three 2024 publications defamed him. According to the second amended complaint filed on 27 August 2026, they are a 14 September 2024 Times article by Ms Craig and Mr Buettner about the making of The Apprentice; their book Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success, published by Penguin Random House on 17 September 2024; and Mr Baker's 20 October 2024 article "For Trump, a Lifetime of Scandals Heads Toward a Moment of Judgment".

Open hardcover book on a wooden table, illustrating the Lucky Loser book at the centre of the Trump New York Times lawsuit
Six of the seven statements that survive come from the 2024 book Lucky Loser.

Each publication carries two counts, defamation per se and per quod. The complaint demands compensatory damages "not less than $15,000,000,000", punitive damages and a retraction. The Guardian reported that the statements cover Mr Trump's role in creating The Apprentice, his inheritance, his business ventures and his upbringing.

The original 85-page complaint, filed on 15 September 2025, was struck four days later; Judge Merryday wrote that a complaint "is not a megaphone for public relations". The amended complaint of 16 October 2025 dropped a sixth defendant, Times correspondent Michael S. Schmidt. The docket also records a mediation on 6 May 2026 that ended without agreement (see our guide to mediation vs arbitration) and a 6 July 2026 refusal to move the case to New York. The Times and Penguin deny defaming Mr Trump; according to The Guardian, a Times spokesperson has said the lawsuit "remains obviously meritless".

Why the judge refused to dismiss the core claims

The judge kept seven statements because, on the facts pleaded, the defendants plausibly knew they lacked the expert basis to accuse Mr Trump of complex tax crimes. Six come from Lucky Loser, including that Mr Trump "had received the equivalent of more than $400 million from his father, much of it through fraudulent tax evasion schemes" and that Fred Trump had given his son "taxable gifts masquerading as loans, a likely tax fraud". The seventh, from the October 2024 article, says authorities "found violations of money laundering rules".

The defendants answered, as The Hollywood Reporter noted, that the authors analysed about 100,000 pages of records and relied on experts, including a tax specialist who called the arrangements "highly suspicious" and a former Manhattan prosecutor who said the scheme "smells like a crime". The judge was not persuaded. A qualified expert's remark that a transaction is "suspicious" or "could" be unlawful, he wrote, "is far from a formal legal opinion" capable of removing serious doubt about an accusation of fraud against a named person.

The key passage reasons that detecting these tax crimes is "intensely fact-dependent". Anyone who publishes such an accusation without "an explicit opinion from a qualified source after a thorough examination of pertinent facts necessarily proceeds with particularized reason to doubt the truth", the order says: "they know that they don't know, but they are undeterred." Knowingly failing to obtain that opinion is, in the judge's words, "a fine example of the purposeful avoidance of the truth".

Actual malice after New York Times v Sullivan

Actual malice is the test a public official must meet to recover for defamation. The Supreme Court held in New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (1964) that the First Amendment bars recovery for a defamatory falsehood about official conduct unless the statement was made "with knowledge that it was false or with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not", and that the proof must have "convincing clarity".

Columned facade of the US Supreme Court, which set the actual malice test now applied in the Trump New York Times lawsuit
The actual malice standard comes from the Supreme Court's 1964 decision in New York Times Co. v. Sullivan.

The order agrees with the defendants that reckless disregard is "a purely subjective test", that ill will and political motive "play no role", and that poor journalism or failure to investigate will not alone establish it. Those principles disposed of 27 statements.

The surviving claims rest on a narrower point from Harte-Hanks Communications v. Connaughton, quoted in the order: "Although failure to investigate will not alone support a finding of actual malice, the purposeful avoidance of the truth is in a different category." The order puts a known need for specialist opinion, deliberately left unmet, in that category. At this stage the inference need only be plausible; proof comes later.

What the court threw out in the Trump New York Times lawsuit

Counts III and IV, based on the September 2024 article about The Apprentice, were dismissed entirely; the complaint had objected to passages such as a description of worn décor at Trump Tower in 2003. The judge also held the remaining 27 challenged statements across all three publications not actionable, writing that "even if untrue, even if published with ill-will or evil intent, and even if insulting", they fail under Sullivan and the other principles the defendants set out.

Mr Trump may not amend again, so the case proceeds on the seven statements alone, although the order leaves open whether evidence about the other 27 is admissible at trial.

What happens next: answer, discovery and appeal

The defendants must answer within 28 days, and discovery on the surviving counts follows. As actual malice turns on what the authors believed, discovery is likely to reach drafts, notes and expert consultations. In the BBC case the broadcaster has pressed Mr Trump for financial records.

After discovery, either side may seek summary judgment under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56, which applies where there is "no genuine dispute as to any material fact". Mr Trump will then need evidence of actual malice. He has demanded a jury, and large verdicts can still be revisited after trial, as the Apple Taptic Engine patent case shows.

An immediate appeal is unlikely. A refusal to dismiss is not a final decision, and under 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b) an interlocutory appeal needs the district judge to certify a "controlling question of law as to which there is substantial ground for difference of opinion", and the Court of Appeals to agree to hear it.

How the ruling compares with Trump's WSJ and BBC lawsuits

Three Florida federal judges have ruled on Mr Trump's media suits within three weeks. On 31 October 2026, Judge Darrin P. Gayles in Miami dismissed the Wall Street Journal lawsuit with prejudice, finding no plausible allegation of actual malice. The Times defendants filed that order with Judge Merryday on 2 November. On 10 November, Judge Jeffrey T. Kuntz refused to dismiss the $10bn BBC Panorama claim.

CaseCourt and judgeRulingDamages claimed
Trump v. Dow Jones (WSJ)S.D. Fla., Judge GaylesDismissed with prejudice, 31 October 2026$10bn
Trump v. BBCS.D. Fla., Judge KuntzDefamation count proceeds, 10 November 2026$10bn
Trump v. New York TimesM.D. Fla., Judge MerrydayFour of six counts proceed, 19 November 2026At least $15bn

The law was the same in each case; the pleaded facts differed. Accusations of crime said to need expert legal analysis gave this claim a foothold the WSJ claim lacked. For publishers, the lesson is to document expert sign-off before alleging specific offences. Mr Trump has also lost as a defamation defendant: the Carroll judgment funds have been released.

Publishers facing similar claims can find advisers in our US litigation directory and US media and technology listings, or by state, including Florida and New York.

Frequently asked questions

Was Trump's New York Times lawsuit dismissed?

Only in part. On 19 November 2026 Judge Merryday dismissed Counts III and IV and 27 of the 34 challenged statements, but Counts I, II, V and VI proceed on seven statements about alleged tax fraud and money laundering violations.

Who are the defendants in the Trump New York Times lawsuit?

The New York Times Company, reporters Susanne Craig, Russ Buettner and Peter Baker, and Penguin Random House LLC. A sixth reporter named in 2025 was dropped.

What is actual malice?

It is the standard from New York Times Co. v. Sullivan: a public official must show a defamatory statement was published knowing it was false or with reckless disregard for whether it was false. Ill will alone does not meet it.

Why did the judge find actual malice plausibly alleged?

Because the complaint alleges the authors and publishers knew that accusing Mr Trump of complex tax crimes required a qualified legal opinion, and knowingly failed to obtain one. The judge called that a fine example of purposeful avoidance of the truth.

Does the ruling mean the Times defamed Trump?

No. The order decides only that four counts are plausibly pleaded. Mr Trump must still prove the seven statements false and defamatory, and actual malice with convincing clarity.

Can the New York Times appeal the ruling now?

Not as of right. An immediate appeal needs the district judge to certify a controlling question of law under 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b) and the appeals court to accept it. No such request had been reported by 20 November 2026.


Sources

  1. Order on the motion to dismiss, Trump v. New York Times Company (M.D. Fla., 19 November 2026)
  2. CourtListener: docket, Trump v. New York Times Company, No. 8:25-cv-02487
  3. Second amended complaint (27 August 2026)
  4. Order striking the original complaint (19 September 2025)
  5. New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254 (1964)
  6. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56: summary judgment
  7. 28 U.S.C. § 1292: interlocutory decisions
  8. The Guardian: US judge allows Trump's $15bn lawsuit against New York Times to proceed
  9. The Hollywood Reporter: Trump's $15 billion defamation suit moves forward

About this article

This analysis was researched and written by The Corporate INTL Newsroom, which covers cross-border legal, regulatory and business developments for lawyers, professional advisers and financiers in over 150 jurisdictions. It was checked against the court's order, the pleadings and docket, and press reports of the ruling. It is general information, not legal advice; for advice on a specific matter, consult a qualified adviser. Last reviewed 20 November 2026. More analysis is available in our newsroom, and you can subscribe for updates.

Get matched

Looking for legal or business advice?

Tell us what you need and the Corporate INTL team will help you find the right lawyer or adviser from our members in 150+ jurisdictions.

1What you need2Your details

At least 100 characters: 100 to go