The BYD Ti7 is banned from the European Union, for now. On Friday 20 November 2026 the preliminary relief judge of the District Court of The Hague ruled in summary proceedings that the Ti7 seven-seat SUV infringes a registered EU design that Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) holds for the Land Rover Defender. The judge ordered ten BYD companies to stop importing, making, offering, selling, storing or supplying the Ti7 anywhere in the EU, backed by penalty payments of up to €10 million. The UK is not covered.
BYD Ti7 Banned: Why a Dutch Court Barred the Defender Lookalike From the EU
By The Corporate INTL Newsroom · 21 November 2026
This is the next chapter of the dispute that began with JLR's court-ordered seizure of evidence at BYD's Dutch offices. The ruling is provisional, BYD says it will appeal, and JLR must still bring a full case on the merits.
BYD Ti7 banned: the ruling at a glance
JLR won an EU-wide injunction on one of the six EU designs it relied on, and lost its other claims.
| Point | What the judgment says |
|---|---|
| Court and case | District Court of The Hague, preliminary relief judge J.B.J. Hoefnagel, C/09/712003 / KG ZA 26-956, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:34365 |
| Type of proceedings | Kort geding (summary proceedings for a provisional measure); hearing held on 3 November 2026 |
| Right infringed | Registered EU design 005248580-0004, filed 25 April 2018, for the Defender (type L663, 110 body) |
| Who is bound | BYD Europe, BYD Nederland and BYD companies in France, Sweden, Denmark, Germany (two), Hungary, Poland and Italy |
| Scope | Whole EU, starting one week after the judgment is served |
| Penalty | €100,000 per day of non-compliance (or €25,000 at JLR's election), capped at €10 million |
| Refused | UK designs claims, claims against BYD UK, access to seized documents, distribution data, a website notice |
| Next deadlines | Four weeks to appeal; merits case to be started within six months |
The Ti7 has not yet been sold in the EU. The judge found a threatened infringement because BYD had launched it in the UK, said its seven-seat layout was developed for the UK and Europe, promoted it on European channels and would not undertake to keep it out of the EU.
Why the court found the Ti7 infringes JLR's EU design
The judge held that the Ti7 does not produce a different overall impression on the informed user from JLR's registered design, which is the test for infringement of an EU design. Under the EU design regulation, codified as Regulation (EU) 2026/715 and in force since 1 July 2026, protection covers any design that does not produce a different overall impression, taking into account the designer's freedom (article 11). The same regulation renamed the old Community design the EU design.
Three steps shaped the outcome:
- The informed user. Following the Porsche v Autec case law, a car user who knows the models on the market, pays close attention and knows car makers often modernise existing designs.
- The design corpus. The boxy outline, upright windows, flat roof and high shoulder line are "Defender DNA" dating to 1948 and appear in earlier cars, with the Ford Flex, Jeep Wrangler and Mercedes G-Class as reference points. That narrows the protection.
- What is distinctive. Against that background, the design is marked out by its rounded, bulging shoulders and corners, the "signature panel" forming the rear pillar, the rounded wheel-arch cut-outs, the continuous glasshouse, its proportions and its overall silhouette.
Those dominant features are almost identical in the Ti7, the judge found. BYD did not dispute the similarities but listed many differences, from the headlamps, grille and recessed bonnet to the missing "alpine windows" and a broken shoulder line. Separately and together, the judge held, they were not striking enough to change the overall impression, and the gap between the Ti7 and the design is smaller than the gap between the design and the earlier SUVs. That is the core of the BYD Defender copy finding, though the word "copy" is the press's: design infringement does not require proof of copying.
Because design 1 was enough, the judge did not rule on BYD's validity challenges to designs 2 to 6, and rejected BYD's complaint that JLR's tiny design images and missing seventh view made a fair comparison impossible.
Why the BYD Ti7 is not banned in the UK
The Ti7 remains on sale in Britain because the Dutch court would not rule on British rights against the company selling it there. Since Brexit, EU designs no longer cover the UK. According to UK government guidance, every registered Community design existing on 1 January 2021 was replaced by a re-registered UK design, an independent UK right keeping the same filing date. JLR relied on those UK twins as well.
The claim failed for three reasons:
- No jurisdiction over BYD UK. BYD (U.K.) Co., Limited is not a subsidiary of BYD Europe and could not reasonably expect to be sued in the Netherlands over acts in Britain.
- No proof of Dutch involvement. The UK announcements were on BYD UK's website; a footer mention of BYD Europe did not make the Dutch companies responsible.
- No jurisdiction for the other EU companies. JLR did not show that the French, German and other BYD companies were involved in UK sales.
BYD's own UK announcement of 31 July 2026 priced the Ti 7 from £47,995, with first cars in showrooms in November and customer deliveries in January 2027. Stopping those sales would need UK proceedings. The Defender's shape has a mixed UK record: in JLR v Ineos (2020), the High Court upheld the refusal of UK trade mark applications for the shapes of the earlier Defender 90 and 110. Brand owners weighing UK action can find UK intellectual property advisers in our directory.
What JLR and BYD said
Both companies spoke briefly. "We protect our intellectual property and take legal action when necessary," JLR said in a statement reported by Reuters, adding that it would not comment further while proceedings continue. BYD said it "strongly disagrees" with the ruling and will appeal, maintaining that the Ti 7 "is the result of BYD's own independent design work and infringes none of JLR's rights".
Reuters reported that the Defender, JLR's most popular model, sold over 100,000 units globally in 2025, while BYD's European sales more than doubled to over 280,000 in the first nine months of 2026. The injunction also binds BYD's Hungarian company, which is to run BYD's car factory in Szeged. The judge reasoned that an EU Ti7 could plausibly be built there.
Kort geding: what a Dutch preliminary injunction means and what happens next
A kort geding is a fast Dutch procedure for provisional relief; its outcome is a preliminary view, not a final finding. Next steps:
- Appeal. Under article 339 of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure (Rv), an appeal against a summary judgment must be lodged within four weeks. The injunction applies while any appeal runs.
- Merits case. Under article 1019i Rv the judge set six months from 20 November 2026 for JLR to start full proceedings. If it does not, BYD can make the injunction lapse by filing a declaration with the court registry.
- Rotterdam. JLR has brought a separate kort geding in Rotterdam on copyright and slavish imitation, with a hearing listed for 25 November 2026.
JLR's other requests failed because the Ti7 has not been sold in the EU, echoing an earlier loss: in a judgment of 11 November, corrected on 12 November, the same court lifted JLR's evidence seizure, held that BYD had forfeited no penalties and ordered JLR to pay €25,376.57 in costs, because no sales meant no damage yet to prove. This time BYD pays costs, but only €2,685.12 on the standard scale, because JLR's specification of €55,200.50 in fees was too thin. Our guides to handling a raid and tackling infringers cover the wider toolkit.
Lessons for car makers and brand owners enforcing designs in Europe
A registered EU design, enforced through one court, can shut a product out of 27 markets before launch. Key points:
- Register early. JLR filed in April 2018, well before the Defender's launch on 10 September 2019. A registered EU design can last 25 years; an unregistered one lasts three years and protects only against copying.
- Pick the forum. Suing in the defendant's home member state gives EU-wide jurisdiction (articles 121 and 122 of the regulation), and BYD Europe's Dutch seat gave JLR its anchor; compare cross-border patent claims after BSH v Electrolux and at the Unified Patent Court.
- Act before launch. A threatened infringement supports an injunction, but not disclosure or corrective notices.
- Treat the UK separately. Keep re-registered UK designs alive and plan UK proceedings against the UK seller.
- Do not lean on shape marks. Shape trade marks often fail for lack of distinctiveness, as JLR found with the old Defender and as the Chiquita ruling shows; our guide to registering rights internationally covers filing strategy.
For manufacturers, the lesson is design clearance before an EU launch. Groups setting up an EU base should weigh it alongside Dutch company structuring and the Foreign Subsidies Regulation. Our directory lists intellectual property specialists and litigators in the Netherlands.
Frequently asked questions
Is the BYD Ti7 banned in the UK?
No. The Dutch court declined jurisdiction over BYD UK and rejected JLR's claims on its UK designs, so the injunction covers only the EU.
Why was the BYD Ti7 banned in the EU?
The Hague judge found that the Ti7 produces no different overall impression on the informed user from JLR's registered EU design for the Defender, given its shoulders, signature panel, wheel arches, glasshouse and proportions. Because BYD would not rule out EU sales, the threat justified an injunction.
Did BYD copy the Land Rover Defender?
The court did not decide that. Registered design infringement turns on overall impression, not copying. BYD says the Ti 7 is its own independent design work. JLR's copyright claims run separately in Rotterdam.
Can BYD appeal the ruling?
Yes. BYD has said it will appeal. Dutch law allows four weeks to appeal a summary judgment, and the injunction is provisionally enforceable, so it applies in the meantime unless lifted.
How long does the EU ban last?
It is provisional. JLR must start a merits case within six months of 20 November 2026; otherwise BYD can make the injunction lapse.
What penalty does BYD face if it breaches the order?
Each bound BYD company must pay JLR €100,000 for each day or part day of non-compliance, or €25,000 at JLR's election, up to €10 million in total.
Sources
- Rechtbank Den Haag, 20 November 2026, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:34365 (JLR v BYD, kort geding)
- Rechtbank Den Haag, 12 November 2026, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2026:33456 (corrected judgment lifting the evidence seizure)
- Regulation (EU) 2026/715 on European Union designs (codification)
- Dutch Code of Civil Procedure (Wetboek van Burgerlijke Rechtsvordering), articles 339 and 1019i
- GOV.UK: Changes to EU and international designs and trade mark protection
- Reuters (via Yahoo Finance UK): Dutch court bars Chinese SUV in Europe over resemblance to Land Rover Defender
- Auto Express: BYD's Land Rover Defender copy banned by court
- BYD UK: pricing and specifications of the Ti 7 (31 July 2026)
- Jaguar Land Rover Ltd v Ineos Industries Holdings Ltd [2020] EWHC 2130 (Ch)
About this article
This analysis was researched and written by The Corporate INTL Newsroom, which covers cross-border legal, regulatory and business developments for lawyers, professional advisers and financiers in over 150 jurisdictions. It was checked against the published Dutch judgments, the EU design regulation, Dutch procedural law, UK guidance and press reports. It is general information, not legal advice; for advice on a specific matter, consult a qualified adviser. Last reviewed 21 November 2026. More analysis is available in our newsroom, and you can subscribe for updates.
Looking for legal or business advice?
Tell us what you need and the Corporate INTL team will help you find the right lawyer or adviser from our members in 150+ jurisdictions.