The DRAM lawsuit against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron will go ahead. On Saturday 14 November 2026, US District Judge Noël Wise in San Jose denied the three chipmakers' joint motion to dismiss a putative class action that accuses them of conspiring since October 2022 to restrict the supply of conventional memory chips, the DRAM inside every PC, phone and server. The plaintiffs say conventional DRAM prices rose 697% over eighteen months while none of the three expanded output.
DRAM Lawsuit: Why a US Judge Let the Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Price-Fixing Case Proceed
By The Corporate INTL Newsroom · 16 November 2026
The ruling is not a finding that anyone fixed prices. It decides only that the complaint pleads enough to move into discovery, the stage where the companies must hand over documents. That is still a significant step: a near-identical case over the 2016 to 2018 memory price spike was thrown out at this same stage, and the Ninth Circuit upheld that dismissal in 2022. This article explains what Judge Wise decided, why she said this case is different, what happens next, and what the decision means for buyers in the US, the UK, the EU and South Korea.
What the judge decided in the DRAM lawsuit
Judge Wise held that the plaintiffs had plausibly alleged a conspiracy under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, which makes illegal every contract, combination or conspiracy in restraint of trade among the states or with foreign nations. She refused to dismiss the federal claim and the parallel claims under California, Florida, Minnesota, New York and Wisconsin law, because both sides agreed the state claims rise and fall with the federal one.
The case is Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., No. 5:26-cv-06345-NW, in the US District Court for the Northern District of California. The order appears on the docket as ECF No. 68 and is dated 14 November 2026.
| Point | Detail |
|---|---|
| Court | US District Court, Northern District of California (San Jose) |
| Judge | Noël Wise, US District Judge |
| Case number | 5:26-cv-06345-NW |
| Complaint filed | 25 June 2026 |
| Plaintiffs | 17 named consumers and small businesses from five US states, suing for a proposed class |
| Defendants | Samsung Electronics and Samsung Semiconductor, SK Hynix's US company, Micron Technology |
| Claims | Sherman Act Section 1; state antitrust and consumer protection laws |
| Ruling | Motion to dismiss denied, 14 November 2026 |
| Next deadlines | Answers due 7 December 2026; case management conference 12 January 2027 |
What the plaintiffs say Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron did
The complaint alleges four strands of parallel conduct, all aimed at keeping conventional DRAM scarce. The court summarised them as follows, taking the allegations as true for this stage only:
- Production cuts. SK Hynix announced DRAM cuts on 26 October 2022 and Micron followed on 16 November 2022. Samsung said in January 2023 there would be no artificial production cut, then announced cuts on 7 April 2023.
- A pivot to HBM. From 2023 all three moved capacity to high bandwidth memory for AI accelerators, which the complaint says needs three to four times the wafer area per gigabyte of DDR5.
- A DDR4 exit. Between April and June 2025 all three said they would wind down mainstream DDR4, while it was still widely used. Older DDR4 came to cost more per gigabyte than newer DDR5.
- No re-expansion. Despite record prices, none expanded or announced plans to meaningfully expand commodity DRAM capacity, while smaller rivals did.
The price figures in the complaint are stark. Conventional DRAM prices rose 171.8% in the year to the third quarter of 2025. Contract prices then rose about 50% in the fourth quarter of 2025, 93% in the first quarter of 2026 and 58% in the second, and retail prices rose 500% from early October 2025. The complaint also points to Micron's decision, announced on 3 December 2025, to close its 30-year-old Crucial consumer brand, and to customer-vetting questions that all three introduced in January 2026.
The three companies dominate the market. As of the third quarter of 2025 they held over 91% of global DRAM revenue, according to the complaint, and TrendForce's market data put SK Hynix at 33.2%, Samsung at 32.6% and Micron at 25.7% of a US$41.4 billion quarter. That concentration is why the case turns on a narrow legal question.
Why this case survived when DRAM II did not
The central issue was whether the case is a rerun of DRAM II, the 2018 class action over the 2016 to 2018 price spike. There, the Ninth Circuit held that plaintiffs relying on parallel conduct must plead "some further factual enhancement" placing that conduct in a context suggesting a prior agreement. Judge Wise's answer was short: the court finds that it is not a rerun.
In an oligopoly, firms that copy each other without agreeing anything, known as conscious parallelism, do not break the law. To get past a motion to dismiss, a plaintiff must add "plus factors" that make an agreement plausible. The standard comes from the US Supreme Court's 2007 decision in Bell Atlantic v. Twombly, which the order applies through the Ninth Circuit's DRAM II ruling. Judge Wise grouped the plaintiffs' arguments into eight plus factors:
| Plus factor alleged | Court's view |
|---|---|
| HBM pivot, AI supply lock-ups, Crucial closure, refusal to re-expand | Weighs for plaintiffs (the pivot alone would not) |
| Halting or delaying new DRAM fabs | Weighs for plaintiffs |
| Simultaneous exit from DDR4 | Weighs for plaintiffs |
| Near-identical customer vetting from January 2026 | Strongly supports an inference of conspiracy |
| Public statements to investors | Not enough, as in DRAM II |
| Meetings at industry conferences | Not relied on without evidence of what was exchanged |
| Concentrated market structure | Neutral |
| The 1998 to 2002 criminal cartel | Weighs for plaintiffs |
The key distinction is reversibility. Cutting output or raising prices can be undone next quarter, so a firm can take the lead and wait to see if rivals follow. Years-long supply contracts, shutting a profitable brand and cancelling fabs cannot be unwound easily. The judge said these moves, at the pleading stage, appear to be the kind no reasonable firm would make without a prior agreement, and borrowed the Ninth Circuit's reasoning on refinery capacity in the petroleum cases.
She also rejected Judge Posner's well-known line that competitors in concentrated markets watch each other like hawks. In her words, the allegations here are "more akin to hawks flying in formation". The customer-vetting point weighed heavily: a GPU and server supplier quoted in the complaint said the three companies became stricter and asked who the chips were for, how much and whether demand was real. The order compares that to the monitoring used by the earlier cartel. Information exchange between competitors is a recurring theme in US enforcement, as our report on the RealPage rent-setting settlement shows.
What the court did not accept
The order is not a clean sweep for the plaintiffs. Judge Wise set aside the DDR3 allegations altogether, because the complaint admits Micron kept making DDR3, so that exit was neither parallel nor unusual. She agreed with the defendants that moving into HBM in 2023 and 2024, when HBM was more profitable, was a normal business risk rather than an extreme act against self-interest.
Public statements to investors, including Micron's September 2022 remarks about "supply discipline", did not count, because DRAM II rejected similar statements. Trade conference meetings did not count either, because DRAM II requires plaintiffs to identify what was actually exchanged. These limits matter: in discovery the plaintiffs will need documents that show coordination, not just timing.
The earlier DRAM cartel: fines in the US and the EU
The history counted against the defendants. From 1998 to 2002 the three companies and others ran a criminal cartel to fix DRAM prices. Samsung agreed to plead guilty and pay a US$300 million criminal fine, then the second largest in US antitrust history, and Hynix paid US$185 million. Micron took part but received immunity for reporting the cartel.
Europe acted too. On 19 May 2010 the European Commission fined ten DRAM producers €331,273,800 in its first cartel settlement, including €145,728,000 for Samsung and €51,471,000 for Hynix; Micron again received full immunity. Our guide to how EU cartel fines are calculated explains the leniency and settlement reductions behind those figures.
The defendants argued that a 20-year-old cartel says nothing about today. The court disagreed, following DRAM II: the earlier conspiracy involved the same coordination and the same actors. That does not prove anything new, but it helps the complaint cross the plausibility line.
What happens next in the DRAM lawsuit
The companies must file answers to the complaint by 7 December 2026. The first case management conference is set for Tuesday 12 January 2027, after the court granted the defendants' unopposed request of 23 October 2026 to push back the early deadlines. Discovery should follow, and the plaintiffs will later need to ask the court to certify a class before anyone can recover on behalf of all purchasers.
The stakes are high. A private plaintiff who proves an antitrust injury can recover threefold the damages, plus costs and a reasonable attorney's fee. This is a civil claim; the Sherman Act's criminal penalties, including fines of up to US$100 million for a corporation, apply only if prosecutors bring charges. As with the Nvidia class action, the early rulings shape settlement pressure long before any trial.
Businesses that bought large volumes of memory since 2022 should keep invoices, contract terms and supplier correspondence, including any vetting questionnaires received in 2026. In-house teams weighing whether they are covered by a proposed class, or whether to bring their own claim, can find specialist competition and antitrust advisers in our directory, including US antitrust lawyers and advisers in California.
What it means for buyers in the UK, the EU and South Korea
The named plaintiffs are US consumers and small businesses, and the order says nothing about buyers elsewhere. Buyers outside the US who think they overpaid would need their own route. In the UK, the Competition Act 1998 allows collective proceedings before the Competition Appeal Tribunal, the regime behind the £1.2bn Google Play Store class action. The same tribunal also hears individual damages claims, such as Moy Park's interchange-fee claim. EU buyers would usually sue in national courts, which is easier where a regulator has already found an infringement, as the Commission did in 2010.
Two of the three defendants are Korean, which raises a further option. Private damages claims in Korea rest on the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act, and a Global Law Experts guide on bringing a follow-on antitrust damages action in South Korea notes that a Korea Fair Trade Commission decision helps but is not strictly required, and that Korea has no US-style discovery. Advisers in South Korea can assess that route. Any judgment won abroad also has to be enforced, which our guide on how to enforce a foreign judgment covers. Companies on the receiving end of regulator interest should also read how to prepare for a dawn raid.
Frequently asked questions
Are RAM companies being sued?
Yes. Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron face a putative class action in the Northern District of California, filed on 25 June 2026 by 17 consumers and small businesses. It alleges they conspired from October 2022 to restrict conventional DRAM supply. On 14 November 2026 the judge refused to dismiss it.
What did the judge decide in the DRAM lawsuit?
Judge Noël Wise denied the defendants' joint motion to dismiss, finding the complaint plausibly alleges a Sherman Act conspiracy. She relied on capacity decisions that are hard to reverse, a parallel DDR4 exit, identical customer vetting and the earlier cartel, but not on investor statements or conference meetings.
Does the ruling mean the companies fixed prices?
No. At this stage the court must accept the complaint's factual allegations as true. The ruling only means the claim is plausible enough to proceed to discovery. The companies argue each acted in its own interest, and the plaintiffs still have to prove a conspiracy with evidence.
Is there a DRAM lawsuit payout?
Not yet. No settlement or compensation fund exists and no class has been certified. If the plaintiffs eventually win or settle, US antitrust law allows threefold damages, but any payout per person would depend on a court-approved class, the proof of overcharge and the terms of any settlement.
Is this the same as the old DRAM cartel?
No. The 1998 to 2002 cartel led to US criminal fines, including US$300 million for Samsung, and a €331 million EU fine in 2010. The new case concerns supply restriction from 2022 onwards, but the court treated that history as a factor supporting the new allegations.
Can buyers outside the US join the DRAM lawsuit?
The named plaintiffs come from five US states and the order does not address foreign buyers. Buyers in the UK, the EU or Korea would generally need claims in their own courts, for example collective proceedings before the UK Competition Appeal Tribunal.
Sources
- Order Denying Motion to Dismiss, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., No. 5:26-cv-06345-NW (N.D. Cal. 14 November 2026), ECF No. 68
- In re DRAM Indirect Purchaser Antitrust Litigation, No. 21-15125 (9th Cir. 7 March 2022)
- 15 U.S.C. § 1, Sherman Act Section 1, Legal Information Institute
- 15 U.S.C. § 15, suits by persons injured, Legal Information Institute
- US Department of Justice, Samsung agrees to plead guilty and pay $300 million criminal fine (2005)
- European Commission, IP/10/586, DRAM producers fined €331 million (19 May 2010)
- TrendForce, global DRAM revenue in 3Q25 (26 November 2025)
- Competition Act 1998, section 47B, legislation.gov.uk
- Global Law Experts, How to Bring a Follow-on Antitrust Damages Action in South Korea (2026)
About this article
This article was researched and written by The Corporate INTL Newsroom, which covers cross-border legal, regulatory and business developments for lawyers, professional advisers and financiers in over 150 jurisdictions. The ruling, dates, deadlines and allegations are taken from the court's 14 November 2026 order; the earlier cartel fines from the US Department of Justice and the European Commission; and the statutory text from the US Code and legislation.gov.uk. Allegations in the complaint have not been proven. It is general information, not legal advice; take advice from a qualified competition lawyer before acting. Last reviewed 16 November 2026. For more analysis like this, visit the Corporate INTL newsroom or subscribe to Corporate INTL.
Looking for legal or business advice?
Tell us what you need and the Corporate INTL team will help you find the right lawyer or adviser from our members in 150+ jurisdictions.